RRAJASTHAN NEWS 24News that matters

Home / Rajasthan News / Rajasthan Courts and Anti-Corruption

RAJASTHAN · COURTS · ANTI-CORRUPTION · NOVEMBER 16

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Two-Year Sentence for Former Tonk ASI in Bribery Case

The Jaipur Bench dismissed Noratmal Nolkha’s appeal after finding that recordings, trap evidence, recovery and forensic material proved the bribery charge despite the complainant turning hostile.

Original conceptual illustration of legal papers, a courthouse and a judge’s gavel; not a photograph of the actual case or court hearing.
Original conceptual editorial illustration. It does not depict the actual case file, judge or courtroom.

Jaipur, November 16, 2026: The Rajasthan High Court has upheld a two-year prison sentence imposed on former assistant sub-inspector Noratmal Nolkha in a bribery case dating back to 2007. The Jaipur Bench dismissed his appeal on November 4, holding that the prosecution evidence was sufficient even though the complainant later turned hostile.

The case concerned an alleged demand for ₹1,000 in exchange for submitting a negative final report in a criminal case involving the complainant and his father. The High Court found that recorded conversations, the transcript, currency recovery, forensic evidence and testimony from other witnesses supported the prosecution case. The two two-year sentences under the relevant Prevention of Corruption Act provisions are to run concurrently.

Advertisement

What the case was about

Nolkha was posted at Sop police station in Tonk district when the Anti-Corruption Bureau investigated the complaint. The prosecution case was that he demanded ₹1,000 to submit a negative final report. According to the account reported by the Times of India, ₹300 was allegedly paid on March 24, 2007, and the remaining ₹700 was recovered during an ACB trap the following day.

The trial court convicted Nolkha on December 24, 2019. He challenged the conviction, arguing that the complainant, Om Prakash Bairwa, had turned hostile and denied the demand and acceptance. The appeal also questioned the recorded conversations, the electronic-evidence certificate, the lack of a voice sample and the prosecution sanction.

Why the hostile testimony did not end the case

The High Court did not treat the complainant’s testimony as automatically worthless. It considered the parts of the account that were supported by other evidence, including the recorded conversation and transcript, recovery of currency notes, the forensic science laboratory report and statements from independent witnesses. The bench concluded that the evidence, considered together, proved the demand and acceptance beyond reasonable doubt.

The reasoning follows the principle explained by the Supreme Court’s Constitution Bench in Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi): a corruption prosecution does not necessarily fail because a complainant turns hostile or becomes unavailable. Demand and acceptance may still be established through reliable oral, documentary and circumstantial evidence. That does not remove the prosecution’s burden of proof; it means the court must assess the entire evidentiary record rather than rely on one witness in isolation.

Advertisement

What the court said about electronic evidence

The defence challenged the admissibility of the recorded conversation because a certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act had not accompanied the charge sheet. The High Court rejected the argument in the circumstances of this case, noting that the certificate had been produced before the trial concluded and that the defence had an opportunity to contest the material.

This should not be read as a general rule that electronic records can be admitted without the required certificate. The judgment addresses the timing and circumstances of this prosecution. Courts still examine authenticity, chain of custody, the certificate requirement and whether the opposing party has had a fair chance to challenge the evidence.

Sentence and next legal step

The High Court upheld the conviction under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Both two-year terms are to run concurrently, so they do not add up to four years. The court directed Nolkha to surrender to serve the remaining sentence, with any period already undergone to be accounted for under the applicable rules.

The decision is fact-specific. It does not mean that every corruption case can proceed to conviction when a complainant retracts a statement. The prosecution must still prove the essential elements of the offence with reliable evidence, and the court must assess whether the evidence meets the criminal standard of proof.

Sources and documents

Editorial note: The judgment date is November 4, while the report was published on November 16. The linked LegalRepublic PDF identifies itself as a non-official web copy; readers needing the order for legal proceedings should obtain the certified copy or verify it through the High Court’s official record.

More Rajasthan news · India news