Home / USA / Politics and Elections
U.S. POLITICS · ELECTION LAW · CALIFORNIADOJ Seeks to End California Lawsuit Over 20,000 Disputed Ballots
The Justice Department asked a federal court to dismiss its lawsuit seeking to stop California from counting ballots tied to roughly 20,000 voter registrations it had flagged as potentially ineligible. The department said the ballots had been processed and could no longer be separated.
LOS ANGELES, November 7, 2026: The U.S. Department of Justice has asked to dismiss its lawsuit against California over roughly 20,000 voter registrations that federal officials described as likely belonging to noncitizens. The Associated Press reported that the request was filed Friday, after the 2026 midterm election and ahead of a scheduled hearing on the reliability of the government's list.
What the lawsuit sought
The Justice Department had asked the court to prevent California from counting ballots associated with the registrations until the individuals' immigration status could be checked. The figure of about 20,000 refers to people on a federal list that officials challenged. It is not a verified count of illegal votes, and the allegations do not establish that every person on the list was ineligible to vote.
California officials said the list was outdated and included eligible voters. The judge overseeing the case had rejected the federal government's request to set the ballots aside, warning that separating ballots after voting had begun could disenfranchise eligible voters and disrupt election administration.
Why DOJ says the requested relief is no longer available
According to the Justice Department's filing as described by AP, ballots had already been processed and anonymized. Once a ballot is separated from the envelope that identifies the voter, election officials cannot simply match it back to a particular registration. The department argued that the court could no longer provide the specific relief it originally requested.
AP reported that the department said it would continue pursuing suspected election-law violations through other cases. It also backed a separate lawsuit alleging that California has not done enough to remove ineligible voters from its rolls. That separate case is not the same as the ballot-separation lawsuit covered here.
What the filing does and does not settle
The request concerns the remedy sought in this particular civil case. It does not establish that the federal list was accurate, determine the citizenship of every person identified, or prove that roughly 20,000 unlawful ballots were cast. It also does not resolve broader disputes over federal access to voter-registration records or state election procedures.
The case followed earlier court setbacks for the administration. A Ninth Circuit opinion in the related litigation described the government's difficulty showing that federal law displaced California's election-administration procedures. The court record is important background, but it does not turn the allegations in the voter list into proven facts.
Why it matters for election administration
States and local jurisdictions administer most election procedures, while federal law sets rules for federal elections and voter eligibility. The dispute shows how quickly those responsibilities can collide when a federal agency seeks changes to ballot handling after voting is underway. The practical lesson is that voter-list allegations, court filings and certified election results are different kinds of evidence and should not be treated as interchangeable.
- The Associated Press: U.S. Justice Department drops bid to force California to set aside disputed ballots, Nov. 6, 2026
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit: Order in related California ballot litigation, Nov. 3, 2026
Editorial note: The roughly 20,000 figure refers to registrations on a disputed federal list. It is not a confirmed count of noncitizens who voted. The article describes the Justice Department's request and the positions reported by AP; it does not determine anyone's eligibility.
Related coverage: Latest U.S. news · Politics and elections · Earlier report on California's ballot dispute